Powered by Blogger.

Whom Do We Fear Or Trust?

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Whom Do We Fear Or Trust? (8/5/08)
A pair of Princeton psychology researchers has developed a computer program that allows scientists to analyze better than ever before what it is about certain human faces that makes them look either trustworthy or fearsome.

In doing so, they have also found that the program allows them to construct computer-generated faces that display the most trustworthy or dominant faces possible.

Such work could have implications for those who care what effect their faces may have upon a beholder, from salespeople to criminal defendants, the researchers said.

There's another category of people who have a similar concern – politicians. Hmmm... salespeople, criminal defendants, politicians... lots in common there, no? What's missing from this list... preachers, TV political pundits, military officers... pretty long list.

Unfortunately, we haven't figured out how to run any large society, much less a modern one, without government and government officials, so we're stuck with politicians for some time to come, I'd guess. Well, at least that provides political scientists and researchers into aberrant psychology something to keep busy with.

The research described in the press release above isn't directly about politicians, but it's a sequel to work of the principal investigator (Alexander Todorov) that is:

Who Will Win An Election? Snap Judgments Of Face To Gauge Competence Usually Enough (10/22/07)
A split-second glance at two candidates' faces is often enough to determine which one will win an election, according to a Princeton University study.

Princeton psychologist Alexander Todorov has demonstrated that quick facial judgments can accurately predict real-world election returns. Todorov has taken some of his previous research that showed that people unconsciously judge the competence of an unfamiliar face within a tenth of a second, and he has moved it to the political arena.

His lab tests show that a rapid appraisal of the relative competence of two candidates' faces was sufficient to predict the winner in about 70 percent of the races for U.S. senator and state governor in the 2006 elections.

Other reports on this research: here, here.

Duh. At first glance all he's saying is that people tend to make snap judgments about a candidate's competence... and those candidates go on to win the election. That's not surprising, especially if one hypothesizes that voters tend not to go much beyond their snap judgment. And perhaps that is a valid conclusion, though hardly a welcome one.

In fact, Todorov had already published research showing that people make snap judgments about trustworthiness of people in general:

Snap Judgments Decide A Face's Character, Psychologist Finds (8/22/06)
We may be taught not to judge a book by its cover, but when we see a new face, our brains decide whether a person is attractive and trustworthy within a tenth of a second, according to recent Princeton research.

Princeton University psychologist Alex Todorov has found that people respond intuitively to faces so rapidly that our reasoning minds may not have time to influence the reaction -- and that our intuitions about attraction and trust are among those we form the fastest.

OK, if Todorov's research is sound, people make snap judgments about whom they will trust or fear. So it would be useful to know more precisely what factors those judgments are based on. His latest research has tried to do just that. Quoting again from the latest press release:
Based on this data, the scientists found that humans make split-second judgments on faces on two major measures -- whether the person should be approached or avoided and whether the person is weak or strong.

From there, using a commercial software program that generates composites of human faces (based on laser scans of real subjects), the scientists asked another group of test subjects to look at 300 faces and rate them for trustworthiness, dominance and threat. Common features of both trustworthiness and dominance emerged. A trustworthy face, at its most extreme, has a U-shaped mouth and eyes that form an almost surprised look.

An untrustworthy face, at its most extreme, is an angry one with the edges of the mouth curled down and eyebrows pointing down at the center. The least dominant face possible is one resembling a baby's with a larger distance between the eyes and the eyebrows than other faces. A threatening face can be obtained by averaging an untrustworthy and a dominant face.

This is all rather discouraging. What is not addressed (yet) is how accurate such snap judgments are, especially as regards trustworthiness and competence of political candidates.

It's hardly as though perspicacious people haven't been thinking about such issues for a very long time, of course. If I knew Plato better, I'm sure there'd be some choice observations in there somewhere to cite. Sort of goes along with what he said about the kind of judgments of reality made by people who can observe only shadows on the walls of a cave.

But another astute observer of human nature did have something to say about judging the intentions of people just from studying faces:

There's no art
To find the mind's construction in the face
He was a gentleman on whom I built
An absolute trust.

(Shakespeare, Macbeth, Act 1, Scene 4. This is spoken by King Duncan, regarding the Thane of Cawdor, who has just been executed for treason. Macbeth enters right after this remark, and Duncan makes him the new Thane. Slow learner, that Duncan.)

Interestingly, one of Todorov's conclusions is that the kind of face people find most trustworthy is one that features, basically, a smile. Here's Shakespeare's take on that, in words he gives to Hamlet:

O villain, villain, smiling, damn├Ęd villain!
My tables—meet it is I set it down
That one may smile, and smile, and be a villain
(Hamlet, Act 1, Scene 5)

I have addressed previous similar studies along the same lines (by other investigators) here and here.

Discouraging? Yes. Especially so if this research were to accurately describe most of the electorate. But perhaps it would be better to look at whether there are subsets of the electorate that behave quite differently. Perhaps it would work to divide the (potential) electorate into those who have at least some interest in and knowledge of politics and government, and those who don't and basically don't give a damn.

In particular, there is some evidence that "undecided" voters, those who can't make up their minds until just before voting (if they vote at all) don't simply have a difficult time making a careful judgment. Instead, many "undecideds" are actually "low-information" voters, who don't follow politics very closely, and don't especially enjoy the process. Here are some (obviously partisan) anecdotal observations on this from the 2004 election.

If this is correct, then we can write off maybe 40-50% of the potential electorate as a random factor which is basically uninformed about and uninterested in details of politics and government. If they vote at all, their votes will be based largely on impressionistic factors of appearance, charisma, or group identity – snap judgments from the physical appearance of candidates, perhaps. Although many of them won't vote, those that do might make up perhaps 10% of the total, and they are fully capable of swinging any election in one direction or another.

It is often said that a deciding factor in the 1960 presidential election was that in the first televised debate between Kennedy and Nixon, the latter was recovering from illness, looked weak, and had a decided 5 o'clock shadow. Nixon lost the popular vote by only 120,000 votes. Given how things turned out after Nixon came back to win the office in 1968, the judgments people made in 1960 may not have been so bad. But still such judgments seem like little more than a coin toss.

Further reading:

Poli Psy? – September 2000 online Scientific American article about the "shallowness" of criteria some voters use in voting decisions

The functional basis of face evaluation – June 2008 research article in PNAS about the research described in the first-mentioned press release

Inferences of Competence from Faces Predict Election Outcomes – June 2005 research article in Science by Todorov et al on the relationship between neotenous appearance and perceived competence

Appearance DOES Matter – June 2005 commentary in Science on the preceding article


No comments:

Post a Comment


Knowledge Link Suggest

Drug Abuse Online Lottery Games Drug Abuse Health and Fitness Health and Fitness free music downloads Law Reports Wallpapers Artist online shop originals Product Auto Parts Web Developer online shop originals Product Insurance Company Health Life Technology System Home Security Beauty Cosmetic Online Travel Agency Linux Tips Guide Shooting Simulator Gadgets Technology Project Build Houses Payday Loans Health News Information Animals Shop Travel Agency North Owl Network Dentist Healthy Aging asian pretty The Tool Hospital Barbecook Best way to make Money with Forex Trading Green Home Design Online Lottery atozbythesea.eu.org augmentezvosventes.eu.org automobielbedrijf.eu.org aworldofwindows.eu.org aws-orgware.eu.org azregionalmls.eu.org bacimamma.eu.org Business Plan Competition travel channel and rental cars Pharmacy and drugs Criminal Justice Planning Agency Lawyers Association The Best of Insurance http://celebritytidings.eu.org http://livingandfashion.eu.org Academic Advising Audio logo Stock Audio auto repair advice guide Healthy Women Medical Centre busy with business Car Finance Tools Debt Settlement Lawyer crafty stash corner cuentas and colors Cheap Wedding Dresses drug abuse statistics Lifestyle Home Solutions education essay titles finance insurance premium Lawyer and Legal Information guide healthy recipes health problems of children health topics kids home decorating service home improvement project home improvement project management home improvement project planning home insurance morgages house insurance plan house insurance progressive The Savings Bank insurance agency business loans insurance business loans insurance premium loan legacy landscape blocks legacy landscape contractors legacy landscape materials personal insurance loan real estate for commercial Bedroom Furniture Lawyer Requirements Concept Design teach about alcohol abuse technology support autocar the family deal tile flooring ideas tips lifetime fitness tips reduce car insurance quotes Online Jewelry Stores traveller hotel Insurance and Finance Auto and Parts wood flooring ideas the networks board game Adult Learning Theories sexy lingerie tattoo designs wallpaper artist health category insurance financial category Category Online Money Category Home Improvement online business category Category software games and android category marketing advertising category marketing advertising Home Solution Real Estate Financing Lucepedia Sports and Fitness Train Now Business Economy Global auto car loans car loans insurance Health Information how to prevent diabetes Best Credit Cards Cheap Wedding Dresses Small Business Finance Systems Body Health Home Improvement Services Guide Android Apps and Games fashion design Alcoholism Android Phones Board Games Cheap Tickets and Vacation Packages Online Prevent Child Obesity Prevent Premature Ejaculation Labor Lawyers Home Interior Design Ideas plumbers and carpet cleaning service diet and slimming Beautiful Picture Doctors Dental Care music video art BurningPedia Guide Planning Home Improvement Beauty Cosmetic Web Development Company lawyer requirements Books On Children Education security innovation work iPhone and iPad Turkey The Medical School Barbecue Electric The Linux Documentation Project Mental Health Care New Car Buying Guide House Curtains Dentist All System Education iPhone Specifications Cloud Trading Strategy mortgages and loans Pharmaceutical Info Online Application Service Provider The Masterchef Business Service Delivery Arts and Entertainment Pokerstars Real Money The Masterchef Electric Motors Gadgets Technology Casino Zone Small Business Solutions Home Advice Fashion Design Clothing Adventure Games Health and Fitness Hospital Equipment Plan Life Insurance public transportation services Prevent Premature Ejaculation Best Professional Carpet Cleaning Web Hosting Vehicle Emissions Inspection Drug Abuse Collection Travel Agency Medical Herbs color vision casting Aromatherapy Tips community film Cardio Tips Top Best Home Improvements Article Marketing Colon Cleanse Tips Terms and Conditions of Sale Products for Treating Acne Scars Natural Beauty Products Seo Web Marketing Business Prospects Trade Online Tool House Cleaner Bathing Equipment Financial Solutions Credit Loans Business Insurance Best Supplements Online Affiliate Marketing Web Design Jobs Online Business Degrees Travel and Leisure Hotel Business Online Payment Processor Women Management Criminal Law Marketing Product Webdesign Transportation Services The Marketing Business Prospects Trade Online Shop bed furniture free movies online Direct Hardware Supply Free Download PDF Technology Ipad doctors Specials Medical Dictionary Legacy Landscape Bank South Pacific Carpet Cleaner Best Internet Business Seo Web Marketing Doctor Healthy Doctors Diet Program Health Benefits of Drinking Water ups pills drugs Best Supplements dynasty fine jewelry Ceramic Floor Tile Online Business Degrees Property Residential and Commercial Real Estate All About Medical Bankruptcy Prevent Child Obesity Handbag and Shoes Education of Children physiotherapy school Cheap Airline Tickets Healthy Life PET online Interzoo Rehabilitation Center electric hybrid vehicles Baidu Software Center Automotive Advertising Agencies Health and Care Virtual private network Student Education Technosound Wedding Dresses excel archives Classic Car Restoration Defense Audit Banking Travel and holiday Forex Trading Jobs Cheap Car Insurance Opening the Book Safe Chemical Act Presspeople System Software Plan Life Insurance Top Best Home Improvements Cheap Car Insurance Auto Parts and Service Swiss Business Acting in Real Time Fitness Equipment Tips Bodybuilding Tips Search Engine Optimization Cardio Tips Beauty Salon Express The Best Advice Lawyer Advice Associated With Online Payday Spa and Wellness Center Packages Holiday Travel European Countries Tours Small Business Finance Electronic Cigarette Commercial Law Advice on Travel Planning Home and Family All System Education Graphic Visual Photo business between countries Shop Online Financial Security Authority Latest Fashion Trends Photoshop Wallpaper Real Estate Agents Micro Cogeneration Beauty Products Business Travel Insurance International Trucks For Sale Hair Tonic Top Web Design Business Financial Touring Start Vehicle Emissions Inspection Business Service Delivery Insurance and Finance Web Design Business Shopping Online Insurance Processing Systems Electric System Vehicle Blood Medicine European Vehicle Market Pharmaceutical Section Home sale Beauty Therapy Acupuncture Recipes Kitchen Restaurant Hardwood Flooring Resident Services The Masterchef Employment and the Economy Free Web Design Paint Creations Travel Insurance SEO Consulting Services Car Insurance Loans Doctors Dental Care Vehicle Wash Systems Search Engine Marketing Online Education Schools Natural Beauty Site Cheap Wedding Dresses annuaire automobile episiotomy and pregnant Westerly Lawyers Healthcare Travel Vacations Cheap iPhone Specifications The ReaL Estate Event Online Pharmacy and Drugstore Music Video Art CareCredit Cloud Trading Strategy House Cleaning Services Interoperability the talent agency Good Home Design shooting simulator Independent Port Services The Hotel Sax The Digital Money Booking Tickets and Hotels Online Business Loans Department of Pharmacy Law Free Credit Report football development Trending in Entertainment Prison Education Sexy Lingerie Wood Flooring Ideas Dealer Optics and Ophthalmology Car Insurance Online Urbanism and Architecture Electronic money International Conference on Education Dental Care Auto Repair Shop Auto Repair Advice Guide Dental Clinic Online Pharmacy Debt Consolidation Loans Free Software Smartphone Advice on benefits Insurance Providence Real Estate Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator Fashion Magazine Substance Abuse Education And Technology Marketing Strategy The Best Payday Advance Incident Report Criminal Accounting Books Caring for Pets Real Estate Financing Banking Software Solutions Financial Solutions Credit Loans Full Service Research Agency Discover our free games Business Prospects Trade Online Restaurant Hood Cleaning how to start a business Women's Health and Beauty Payday Loans Criminal Attorney Lawyers Travel and Tourism Fashion Designer The Food Products Fitness and Sports The Beginner's Guide to Businesses Tips To Make SEO Techniques Online Payday Loans Medical Advocate Englisch Training Online Drivers Education Auto Parts and Service Best hotels cheap sport shoes Dental Work Insurance Company Android Phones Financial Advice Service Mobile phone Free Credit Report  The Hair Tonic Advantage Car Rental Information Civil Law Information Payday Cash Loans Payday Cash Loans Advance Affordable Auto Insurance Effective Quality Services Car seats Product Interactions Specialist Medicina Natural Traveller and Hotel European Investment Bank Vehicle Electrical System Pet Food Shop Online Lawyer Employment Plaza Ballroom Weddings Art School The best form of insurance solutions Advice on benefits Insurance Medical coding Tutor Buying Safe Products Free Online Game Famous Fashion Designers Education in Music Virtual Currency Systems Learn Trading Folktronica music Digital currency Manufacturing Engineering Technology Fashionista The Money System Explained Good Marketing In Business Technology Ipad Real Estate Bubble CarePass for Android Business Direct Marketing Carpet Cleaner Natural Beauty Products Seo Web Marketing Business Prospects Trade Online Tool House Cleaner Bathing Equipment Financial Solutions Credit Loans Business Insurance Best Supplements Online Affiliate Marketing Web Design Jobs Online Business Degrees Travel and Leisure Hotel Property Residential and Commercial Real Estate All About Medical Bankruptcy Prevent Child Obesity Handbag and Shoes Education of Children Women Management Free Online Slots Games Healthy Life PET online Interzoo Sunrise Health and Rehabilitation Center Presspeople System Software Baidu Software Center Scientific Entrepreneurship Automotive Advertising Agencies Health and Care Virtual private network Student Education Technosound Information network energy sources Niche Dating Classic Car Restoration Defense Audit Banking Travel and holiday Safe Chemical Act Leader in internet information Music Electric The Marketing verb translation country island FILM LITERATURE GOLD STATUS A Short History of Movies Sexy Lingerie Classified ads Inspire Home Design Trauma Clinic Finance Investment Business Marketing Acting in Real Time Glasgow Tourism Herbal Medicine Cheap Car Insurance Quotes Health Pregnancy Professional Graphic and New Media Designers Legal Connect Network Generating Money Online Oregon health plan Slow Cooker Recipes Best Internet Business Terms and Conditions of Sale Products for Treating Acne Scars Hardwoods Furniture Green Tea Fitness Equipment Tips Bodybuilding Tips Forex Trading Article Marketing Colon Cleanse Tips Hair Loss Tips List Building Search Engine Optimization Cardio Tips Aromatherapy Tips Medical Weight Loss Clinic The Benefits Of Moving Insurance Travel Advice Online Dating Security Network Information Green Energy Scheme Group Auto International Business Telecommunication International All Medicine Reviews Marketplace Real Estate Review Clothing Style Management Consulting Real estate Natural Medicine Treatment Natural Beauty Skin Care Products Shop online Marketing Bank rent car guide Fishing Games cheap website traffic Health and Beauty Gambling football Clothes and Accessories Garden and Landscaping Portal Game Online E-commerce Business Car Accident Lawyer Criminal Law Best free Android apps Hotel and Travel Jobs Technology Film Industry Free Music Downloads Solar Installation Search Engine Optimization Life Technologies Football Betting Site Substance Abuse Apartments home improvement contractor job Luxury Car News Law Products and Services Business Web Hosting Company Complaints Diabetes Drug Abuse Marketing Product Make Money Online Living Without Money Apartments Luxury Car News Law Products and Services Growth Technologies Articles on business growth technologies information Health Insurance Management Advisors System Solar Panel Online Trading The Best of Insurance Payday Loans for Bad Credit Financial Solutions Credit Loans Ensure Insurance Plan Financial Management Team Payday Loans Reviews Distributed File System Student Loan Payments Cheap Insurance in Los Angeles Favorite Fashion Styles The Best Savings Rates Manage Student Loans Webshop europe business guide Shop Personal Loans debt consolidation loans Personal Loan Repayment Chiropractic Tables Webdesign Management Concepts Android Software Free Internet Solution the online casino Best Small Business Blogs Sound Beginnings Automotive Electrical Systems Skin Care in Centrum Master Ethique Cher Client Agency Law Sell Products Online Mens Shoes Strategy Business Development Women's shoes Headache Causes Shop Online Clothing Online Pharmacy Healthy Aging Battle Games best electric vehicle Commercial Real Estate Cosmetic Beauty Product Health Medicine Pharmacy Image of the Orient Fashion Jewellery

Blog Archive